Effect of Physician Gender and Race on Simulated Patients' Ratings and Confidence in Their Physicians: A Randomized Trial.

Published on Feb 5, 2020
· DOI :10.1001/JAMANETWORKOPEN.2019.20511
Rachel E. Solnick3
Estimated H-index: 3
(UM: University of Michigan),
Kyle Peyton5
Estimated H-index: 5
(Yale University)
+ 1 AuthorsBasmah Safdar19
Estimated H-index: 19
(Yale University)
Importance Women and black physicians encounter workplace challenges because of their gender and race. It is unclear whether these individuals are assessed with lower patient satisfaction or confidence ratings compared with white male physicians. Objective To examine whether physician gender and race affect participant ratings in scenarios in which physician competence is challenged. Design, Setting, and Participants This randomized trial enrolled a geographically diverse sample of 3592 online respondents in the United States who were recruited from 2 crowdsourcing platforms: Amazon Mechanical Turk (n = 1741) and Lucid (n = 1851). A 2 × 2 factorial design for the gender and race of simulated physicians was conducted between March 9 and July 25, 2018. Participants were excluded before intervention if they were younger than 18 years, were pregnant, or had a history of cancer or abdominal surgical procedures. Interventions A clinical vignette was presented to the participant with a picture of the emergency department physician. Participants were randomly assigned to physicians with different gender and race, with 823 assigned to black women, 791 to black men, 828 to white women, and 835 to white men. A contradictory diagnosis from an online symptom checker introduced doubt about the clinical diagnosis. Main Outcomes and Measures A composite outcome (range, 0-100, with 0 representing low patient confidence and satisfaction and 100 representing the maximum on the composite scale) measured participant (1) confidence in the physician, (2) satisfaction with care, (3) likelihood to recommend the physician, (4) trust in the physician’s diagnosis, and (5) likelihood to request additional tests. Results Among 3277 adult participants, complete data were available for 3215 (median age, 49 years [range, 18-89 years]; 1667 [52%] female; 2433 [76%] white). No significant differences were observed in participant satisfaction and physician confidence for the white male physician control physicians (mean composite score, 66.13 [95% CI, 64.76-67.51]) compared with white female (mean composite score, 66.50 [95% CI, 65.19-67.82]), black female (mean composite score, 67.36 [95% CI, 66.03-68.69]), and black male (mean composite score, 66.96 [95% CI, 65.55-68.36]) physicians. Machine learning with bayesian additive regression trees revealed no evidence of treatment effect heterogeneity as a function of participants’ race, gender, racial prejudice, or sexism. Conclusions and Relevance No significant differences were observed for simulated patients’ evaluations of female or black physicians, suggesting that bias in favor of white male physicians is negligible in survey-based measures of patient satisfaction. Trial Registration ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:NCT04190901
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
8 Authors (Luis Garcia, ..., Latha Palaniappan)
15 Citations
3 Citations
104 Citations
#1M. B. Wheeler (UCSF: University of California, San Francisco)H-Index: 3
#1Margaret Wheeler (UCSF: University of California, San Francisco)H-Index: 3
Last. Alicia Fernandez (UCSF: University of California, San Francisco)H-Index: 29
view all 7 authors...
Importance As the clinical workforce becomes more diverse, physicians encounter patients who demean them based on social characteristics. Little is known about physicians’ perspectives on these encounters and their effects. This knowledge would help develop policies and best practices for institutions and training programs. Objective To describe the range and importance of encounters with biased patients and the barriers and facilitators to effective responses. Design, Setting, and Participants ...
28 CitationsSource
To what extent do survey experimental treatment effect estimates generalize to other populations and contexts? Survey experiments conducted on convenience samples have often been criticized on the grounds that subjects are sufficiently different from the public at large to render the results of such experiments uninformative more broadly. In the presence of moderate treatment effect heterogeneity, however, such concerns may be allayed. I provide evidence from a series of 15 replication experimen...
143 CitationsSource
#1Geordan Shannon (UCL: University College London)H-Index: 11
#2Melanie JansenH-Index: 1
Last. Jenevieve Mannell (UCL: University College London)H-Index: 12
view all 8 authors...
Summary The purpose of this Review is to provide evidence for why gender equality in science, medicine, and global health matters for health and health-related outcomes. We present a high-level synthesis of global gender data, summarise progress towards gender equality in science, medicine, and global health, review the evidence for why gender equality in these fields matters in terms of health and social outcomes, and reflect on strategies to promote change. Notwithstanding the evolving landsca...
103 CitationsSource
#1Alexander Coppock (Yale University)H-Index: 14
#2Oliver A. McClellan (Columbia University)H-Index: 2
Researchers have increasingly turned to online convenience samples as sources of survey responses that are easy and inexpensive to collect. As reliance on these sources has grown, so too have concerns about the use of convenience samples in general and Amazon’s Mechanical Turk in particular. We distinguish between “external validity” and theoretical relevance, with the latter being the more important justification for any data collection strategy. We explore an alternative source of online conve...
148 CitationsSource
#1Sabine C. Jenner (Charité)H-Index: 3
#2Pia Djermester (Charité)H-Index: 2
Last. Sabine Oertelt-Prigione (Charité)H-Index: 19
view all 5 authors...
This cross-sectional internet-based survey study analyzes sexual harassment among physicians in an academic tertiary referral center in Germany.
33 CitationsSource
#1Jonathan de QuidtH-Index: 9
#2Johannes Haushofer (Princeton University)H-Index: 19
Last. Christopher Roth (University of Oxford)H-Index: 11
view all 3 authors...
We propose a technique for assessing robustness of behavioral measures and treatment effects to experimenter demand effects. The premise is that by deliberately inducing demand in a structured way we can measure its influence and construct plausible bounds on demand-free behavior. We provide formal restrictions on choice that validate our method, and a Bayesian model that microfounds them. Seven pre-registered experiments with eleven canonical laboratory games and around 19,000 participants demo...
83 CitationsSource
#1Esther K. ChooH-Index: 23
#2Jane van DisH-Index: 4
Last. Dara Kass (Columbia University)H-Index: 7
view all 3 authors...
Time’s Up for Medicine? Only Time Will Tell Putting an end to the culture of gender-based harassment is key to recruiting, retaining, and realizing the full potential of nearly half the medical workforce. Doing so will depend on our willingness to undergo a complete transformation in how we approach this problem.
34 CitationsSource
#1Aba Osseo-Asare (Yale University)H-Index: 1
#2Lilanthi Balasuriya (Yale University)H-Index: 3
Last. Dowin Boatright (Yale University)H-Index: 13
view all 9 authors...
Importance Black, Hispanic, and Native American physicians remain underrepresented in medicine despite national efforts to increase diversity in the health care workforce. Understanding the unique workplace experiences of minority physicians is essential to inform strategies to create a diverse and inclusive workforce. While prior research has explored the influence of race/ethnicity on the experiences of minority faculty and medical students, there is a paucity of literature investigating how r...
124 CitationsSource
#1Brad N. Greenwood (UMN: University of Minnesota)H-Index: 13
#2Seth Carnahan (WashU: Washington University in St. Louis)H-Index: 9
Last. Laura Huang (Harvard University)H-Index: 14
view all 3 authors...
We examine patient gender disparities in survival rates following acute myocardial infarctions (i.e., heart attacks) based on the gender of the treating physician. Using a census of heart attack patients admitted to Florida hospitals between 1991 and 2010, we find higher mortality among female patients who are treated by male physicians. Male patients and female patients experience similar outcomes when treated by female physicians, suggesting that unique challenges arise when male physicians tr...
148 CitationsSource
#1Daniel Lakens (TU/e: Eindhoven University of Technology)H-Index: 31
#2Anne M. Scheel (TU/e: Eindhoven University of Technology)H-Index: 6
Last. Peder M. Isager (TU/e: Eindhoven University of Technology)H-Index: 9
view all 3 authors...
Psychologists must be able to test both for the presence of an effect and for the absence of an effect. In addition to testing against zero, researchers can use the two one-sided tests (TOST) procedure to test for equivalence and reject the presence of a smallest effect size of interest (SESOI). The TOST procedure can be used to determine if an observed effect is surprisingly small, given that a true effect at least as extreme as the SESOI exists. We explain a range of approaches to determine th...
310 CitationsSource
Cited By7
#1Sarah Bueno Motter (UHSA: University of Health Sciences Antigua)
#2Gabriela Rangel Brandão (UHSA: University of Health Sciences Antigua)
Last. Camila R Guetter (Johns Hopkins University)
view all 9 authors...
We aimed to analyze the representativeness of women surgeons in academic and leadership positions in Brazil. We investigated women representativeness across surgical departments of 25 Brazilian universities (2020); across boards of 10 Brazilian surgical societies (2020), and, as speakers, in 281 surgical events (Jan-2014 to Dec-2020). From 383 individuals in university departments, 43 (11.2 %) were women (p < 0.001). Only three universities had women as department chairs. From 163 positions in s...
#1Lewis Glinert (Dartmouth College)H-Index: 11
Taking the ‘medication experience’ in the broad sense of what individuals hear and say about their medication, as well as how they experience it, this paper explores diverse research on medication information available to patients and their modes and capacities for interaction, including personal circles, doctors and pharmacists, labeling and promotion, websites, and the patient’s own inner conversations and self-expression. The goal is to illustrate, for nonspecialists in communication, how the...
1 CitationsSource
#1Rachel E. Solnick (UM: University of Michigan)H-Index: 3
#2Grace F. Chao (UM: University of Michigan)H-Index: 4
Last. Keith E. Kocher (UM: University of Michigan)H-Index: 16
view all 5 authors...
Background Containment of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic requires the public to change behavior under social distancing mandates. Social media are important information dissemination platforms that can augment traditional channels communicating public health recommendations. The objective of the study is to assess the effectiveness of COVID-19 public health messaging on Twitter when delivered by emergency physicians and containing personal narratives. Methods On April 30, 2020,...
4 CitationsSource
#1Joshua D. Niforatos (Johns Hopkins University)H-Index: 6
#2Alexander Chaitoff (Brigham and Women's Hospital)H-Index: 6
Last. Ali S. Raja (Harvard University)H-Index: 31
view all 5 authors...
Objective The objective of this study was to determine the public's likelihood of being willing to use an emergency department (ED) for urgent/emergent illness during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic. Methods An institutional review board-approved, cross-sectional survey of a non-probability sample from Amazon Mechanical Turk was administered May 24-25, 2020. Change in self-reported willingness to use an ED before and during the pandemic (primary outcome) was assessed via McNemar...
#1Kathryn A. Martinez (Cleveland Clinic)H-Index: 17
#2Kaitlin Keenan (Cleveland Clinic Lerner College of Medicine)H-Index: 1
Last. Michael B. Rothberg (Cleveland Clinic)H-Index: 55
view all 7 authors...
BACKGROUND Patient satisfaction measures have important implications for physicians. Patient bias against non-White physicians may impact physician satisfaction ratings, but this has not been widely studied. OBJECTIVE To assess differences in patient satisfaction by physician race/ethnicity. DESIGN A cross-sectional observational study. PARTICIPANTS Patients seeking care on a large nationwide direct to consumer telemedicine platform between July 2016 and July 2018 and their physicians. MAIN MEAS...
1 CitationsSource
#1Kenneth G. Poole (Mayo Clinic)H-Index: 5
#2Leon McDougle (OSU: Ohio State University)H-Index: 10