Agriculture

Ecology

Biology

Microeconomics

Computer security

Interoperability

Operating system

Food security

Economics

Transparency (behavior)

Computer science

Risk analysis (engineering)

Business

Agrochemical

Political science

Environmental resource management

Externality

Software deployment

Unintended consequences

Nature Machine Intelligence

Global agriculture is poised to benefit from the rapid advance and diffusion of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies. AI in agriculture could improve crop management and agricultural productivity through plant phenotyping, rapid diagnosis of plant disease, efficient application of agrochemicals and assistance for growers with location-relevant agronomic advice. However, the ramifications of machine learning (ML) models, expert systems and autonomous machines for farms, farmers and food security are poorly understood and under-appreciated. Here, we consider systemic risk factors of AI in agriculture. Namely, we review risks relating to interoperability, reliability and relevance of agricultural data, unintended socio-ecological consequences resulting from ML models optimized for yields, and safety and security concerns associated with deployment of ML platforms at scale. As a response, we suggest risk-mitigation measures, including inviting rural anthropologists and applied ecologists into the technology design process, applying frameworks for responsible and human-centred innovation, setting data cooperatives for improved data transparency and ownership rights, and initial deployment of agricultural AI in digital sandboxes. Machine learning applications in agriculture can bring many benefits in crop management and productivity. However, to avoid harmful effects of a new round of technological modernization, fuelled by AI, a thorough risk assessment is required, to review and mitigate risks such as unintended socio-ecological consequences and security concerns associated with applying machine learning models at scale.

Responsible artificial intelligence in agriculture requires systemic understanding of risks and externalities