Positive economics

Neoclassical economics

Sociology

Social structure

Social science

Biology

Politics

Agency (philosophy)

Marxist philosophy

Epistemology

Philosophy

Materialism

Political science

Property (philosophy)

Economics

Ecology

Historical materialism

Reproduction

Structure and agency

Historical Materialism

This essay argues that Knafo and Teschke fundamentally misread Brenner’s original contribution to the transition debate. They equate his rejection of trans-historical or trans-modal laws of motion with the notion that social-property relations do not have strong rules of reproduction that structure the actions of agents and give rise to ‘developmental patterns’ specific to each form of social labour. Knafo and Teschke’s critique of Brenner’s analysis of capitalist expansion and crisis is also theoretically and empirically questionable.

Structure and Agency in Historical Materialism: A Response to Knafo and Teschke