Physics

Sociology

Work (physics)

Qualitative research

Identity (music)

Social science

Liminality

Engineering

Political science

Psychology

Health care

Ambivalence

Acoustics

Anthropology

Hybridity

Public relations

Health professionals

Social psychology

Mechanical engineering

Organization Studies

Recent literature on hybridity has provided useful insights into how professionals have responded to changing institutional logics. Our focus is on how shifting logics have shaped senior medical professionals’ identity motives and identity work in a qualitative study of hospital consultants in the United Kingdom’s National Health Service. We found a binary divide between a large category of traditionalist doctors who reject shifting logics, and a much smaller category of incorporated consultants who broadly accept shifting logics and advocate change, with little evidence of significant ambivalence or temporary identity ‘fixes’ associated with liminality. By developing a new inductively generated framework, we show how the identity motives and identity work of these two categories of doctors differ significantly. We explore the underlying causes of these differences, and the implications they hold for theory and practice in medical professionalism, medical professional leadership and healthcare reform.

Changing Logics in Healthcare and Their Effects on the Identity Motives and Identity Work of Doctors