Ecosystem

Geology

Macroeconomics

Pathology

Arid

Economics

Aridity index

Ecology

Productivity

Primary production

Leaf area index

Vegetation (pathology)

Ecosystem respiration

Eddy covariance

Environmental science

Terrestrial ecosystem

Carbon cycle

Medicine

Biology

Atmospheric sciences

Remote Sensing of Environment

Ecosystem primary productivity is a key ecological process influencing many ecosystem services, including carbon storage. Thus, clarifying how primary productivity in terrestrial ecosystems responds to climatic variability can reveal key mechanisms that will drive future changes in the global carbon budget. Satellite products of canopy greenness are widely used as proxies for vegetation productivity to evaluate how ecosystems respond to climate variability. However, to what degree inter-annual variations in productivity are consistent with greenness and how this relationship varies spatially remains unclear. Here we investigated the strength of the coupling between inter-annual variations in leaf area index (LAI, a measure of greenness) and ecosystem gross primary productivity (GPP) derived from eddy covariance towers, i.e., the r 2 of the LAI-GPP relationship. Overall, inter-annual GPP and LAI were highly coupled (i.e., high r 2 ) in arid grasslands, but were fully decoupled in mesic evergreen broadleaf forests, indicating that this relationship varies strongly along aridity gradients. A possible mechanism of the spatial variation in the LAI-GPP relationship is that the tradeoff between ecosystem structure (LAI) and physiology (photosynthesis per unit leaf area) becomes stronger in more humid climates. Land models overestimated the r 2 of LAI-GPP correlation for most ecosystem types and failed to capture the spatial pattern along aridity gradients. We conclude that relying on greenness products for evaluating inter-annual changes in vegetation productivity may bias assessments, especially in tropical rainforest ecosystems. Our findings may also reconcile observed disparities between responses in greenness and GPP during drought in Amazon forests. • Ecosystem models overestimate the coupling between GPP and greenness. • The dependency of GPP variability on greenness declines with climatic humidity. • GPP and greenness are fully decoupled in tropic rainforests. • Opposite dynamics between canopy structure and physiology caused the decoupling.

Decoupling of greenness and gross primary productivity as aridity decreases