Physics

Sociology

Government (linguistics)

Public service

Administration (probate law)

Civil service

Civil servants

Politics

Algorithm

Economic policy

Philosophy

Political economy

Political science

Economics

Power (physics)

Council of Ministers

European union

Computer science

Linguistics

Quantum mechanics

Public administration

State (computer science)

Bureaucracy

Administration & Society

Patronage is typically studied following government terminations when political parties appoint their nominees into the state administration. However, patronage is understudied in cases when a change of minister takes place without government termination. Taking individual government ministers as the units of analysis, we identify four modalities of ministerial alterations: replacing, successive, incumbent, and switching ministers. We show that politicization occurs under “replacing ministers” following government termination, but the bureaucratic turnover is equally high under “successive ministers.” That suggests that patronage can be seen as an individualized power resource of autonomous ministers who exercise influence independently of their political parties.

Personal or Party Roots of Civil Service Patronage? Ministerial Change Effects on the Appointments of Top Civil Servants