The second pugilist’s plight: Why people believe they are above average but are not especially happy about it.

Published on Mar 1, 2019in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
· DOI :10.1037/XGE0000580
Shai Davidai8
Estimated H-index: 8
(The New School),
Sebastian Deri4
Estimated H-index: 4
(Cornell University)
: People's tendency to rate themselves as above average is often taken as evidence of undue self-regard. Yet, everyday experience is occasioned with feelings of inadequacy and insecurity. How can these 2 experiences be reconciled? Across 12 studies (N = 2,474; including 4 preregistered studies) we argue that although people do indeed believe that they are above average they also hold themselves to standards of comparison that are well above average. Across a host of domains, we find that people's typical standards of comparison are significantly above the level of the "average" person (Studies 1A, 1B, 2A, and 3). We further show that people's tendency to measure themselves against above-average others is due to the increased mental availability of such high-performing standards of comparison (Studies 4A and 4B). Finally, we present evidence that this is not simply the result of self-enhancement by showing that people measure themselves against above-average others even when they feel subjectively inadequate (Study 5A), receive objective information about their poor performance (Study 5B), or evaluate themselves on domains in which they chronically underperform (Study 5C). Even in domains where being above average is undesirable (e.g., rudeness), people bring to mind and compare themselves with above average targets (Studies 2B and 2C). We discuss the implications for self-enhancement research and the importance of examining who people compare themselves to in addition to how people believe they compare with others. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
3 Citations
6 Citations
14 Citations
#1Carey K. Morewedge (BU: Boston University)H-Index: 27
#2Meng Zhu (Johns Hopkins University)H-Index: 9
Last. Eva C. Buechel (SC: University of Southern California)H-Index: 8
view all 3 authors...
8 CitationsSource
Abstract Although the rates of economic inequality in the United States are at their highest since the onset of The Great Depression, many Americans do not seem as concerned as may be expected. This apparent lack of concern has been attributed to people's deeply-entrenched belief in economic mobility – the belief that through hard work, determination, and skill people are able to rise up the economic ladder. Little is known, however, about why Americans so strongly believe in economic mobility. ...
29 CitationsSource
Recent evidence suggests that Americans’ beliefs about upward mobility are overly optimistic. Davidai and Gilovich (2015a), Kraus and Tan (2015), and Kraus (2015) all found that people overestimate the likelihood that a person might rise up the economic ladder, and underestimate the likelihood that they might fail to do so. However, using a different methodology, Chambers, Swan and Heesacker (2015) reported that Americans’ beliefs about mobility are much more pessimistic. Swan, Chambers, Hee...
19 Citations
#1Rachel ShermanH-Index: 10
22 Citations
#1Jennifer E. Dannals (Stanford University)H-Index: 4
#2Dale T. Miller (Stanford University)H-Index: 64
: Social outliers draw a lot of attention from those inside and outside their group and yet little is known about their impact on perceptions of their group as a whole. The present studies examine how outliers influence observers' summary perceptions of a group's behavior and inferences about the group's descriptive and prescriptive norms. Across 4 studies (N = 1,718) we examine how observers perceive descriptive and prescriptive social norms in groups containing outliers of varying degrees. We ...
9 CitationsSource
#1Shai Davidai (The New School)H-Index: 8
#2Thomas Gilovich (Cornell University)H-Index: 74
Research on the structural features of people’s most enduring regrets has focused on whether they result from having acted or having failed to act. Here we focus on a different structural feature, their connection to a person’s self-concept. In 6 studies, we predict and find that people’s most endur
10 CitationsSource
#1Robert H. FrankH-Index: 45
How important is luck in economic success? No question more reliably divides conservatives from liberals. As conservatives correctly observe, people who amass great fortunes are almost always talented and hardworking. But liberals are also correct to note that countless others have those same qualities yet never earn much. In recent years, social scientists have discovered that chance plays a much larger role in important life outcomes than most people imagine. In Success and Luck, bestselling a...
68 Citations
#1Todd Rogers (Harvard University)H-Index: 28
#2Avi Feller (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 17
People are exposed to exemplary peer performances often (and sometimes by design in interventions). In two studies, we showed that exposure to exemplary peer performances can undermine motivation and success by causing people to perceive that they cannot attain their peers’ high levels of performance. It also causes de-identification with the relevant domain. We examined such discouragement by peer excellence by exploiting the incidental exposure to peers’ abilities that occurs when students are...
42 CitationsSource
#1Elizabeth D. Kantor (Harvard University)H-Index: 7
#2Colin D. Rehm (Tufts University)H-Index: 37
Last. Edward Giovannucci (Harvard University)H-Index: 236
view all 5 authors...
Importance It is important to document patterns of prescription drug use to inform both clinical practice and research. Objective To evaluate trends in prescription drug use among adults living in the United States. Design, Setting, and Participants Temporal trends in prescription drug use were evaluated using nationally representative data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES). Participants included 37 959 noninstitutionalized US adults, aged 20 years and older. Sev...
631 CitationsSource
#1Penelope Lockwood (U of T: University of Toronto)H-Index: 17
#2Sarah C. Shaughnessy (U of T: University of Toronto)H-Index: 2
Last. Man-On Tong (U of T: University of Toronto)H-Index: 2
view all 4 authors...
The authors propose that individuals transitioning to a novel environment will prefer upward comparisons, particularly those made with individuals who have experienced a similar transition. Such comparisons help to reduce uncertainty and demonstrate that future success is possible. Study 1 found that individuals facing transitions to unfamiliar situations seek upward comparisons as a result of their uncertainty. Study 2 demonstrated that individuals who perceive themselves to be making a signifi...
16 CitationsSource
Cited By4
#1Shai Davidai (Columbia University)H-Index: 8
#2Sebastian Deri (Cornell University)H-Index: 4
Last. Thomas Gilovich (Cornell University)H-Index: 74
view all 3 authors...
We examine how self-assessments are influenced by readily-accessible extreme exemplars that embody specific traits, skills, or behavioral tendencies. Because individuals who live especially active ...
2 CitationsSource
Abstract People often judge how much “the rich” deserve to be rich by taking into consideration how they had made their wealth. How do people make such judgments about the origins of others' wealth? In nine studies (N = 1707) and two supplemental analyses (N = 197), we examine whether the attributions people make about wealth are influenced by the way wealthy people spend their money. We find that people are more likely to attribute economic success to internal factors (such as hard work and com...
1 CitationsSource
#1Ethan Zell (UNCG: University of North Carolina at Greensboro)H-Index: 19
#2Jason E. Strickhouser (FSU: Florida State University)H-Index: 10
Last. Mark D. Alicke (OU: Ohio University)H-Index: 33
view all 4 authors...
The better-than-average-effect (BTAE) is the tendency for people to perceive their abilities, attributes, and personality traits as superior compared to their average peer. This article offers a comprehensive review of the BTAE and the first quantitative synthesis of the BTAE literature. We define the effect, differentiate it from related phenomena, and describe relevant methodological approaches, theories, and psychological mechanisms. Next, we present a comprehensive meta-analysis of BTAE stud...
26 CitationsSource
#1Shai Davidai (Columbia University)H-Index: 8
#2Martino Ongis (The New School)H-Index: 3
The tendency to see life as zero-sum exacerbates political conflicts. Six studies (N = 3223) examine the relationship between political ideology and zero-sum thinking: the belief that one party’s gains can only be obtained at the expense of another party’s losses. We find that both liberals and conservatives view life as zero-sum when it benefits them to do so. Whereas conservatives exhibit zero-sum thinking when the status quo is challenged, liberals do so when the status quo is being upheld. C...
6 CitationsSource