Aesthetics

Epistemology

Rhetoric

Philosophy

Biology and political orientation

Dialectic

Theology

Politics

Political science

Opposition (politics)

Democracy

Premise

Argumentative

Enlightenment

Journal of Applied Philosophy

Deep disagreements are disagreements wherein the dialectical conditions for fruitful argumentative exchange do not obtain. One view from within these disagreements is that the other side has been duped or is so deeply ignorant of and complacent with some illusion, there is no hope for exchange. The Dark Enlightenment's critique of liberal democracy and progressive politics (which gave rise to the alt‐right movement) proceeds on this premise, calling their critical philosophy ‘the red pill’ and terming the opposition's program ‘the Cathedral’. Despite the depth of their disagreement with progressives, there is evidence for an optimistic program of critical dialogue in this instance of deep disagreement.

Deep Disagreement, the Dark Enlightenment, and the Rhetoric of the Red Pill