CollAborative care for Screen-Positive EldeRs with major depression (CASPER plus): a multicentred randomised controlled trial of clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness.

Published on Nov 1, 2017in Health Technology Assessment3.37
· DOI :10.3310/HTA21670
Katharine Bosanquet5
Estimated H-index: 5
(Ebor: University of York),
Joy Adamson34
Estimated H-index: 34
(Ebor: University of York)
+ 32 AuthorsSimon Gilbody80
Estimated H-index: 80
(Ebor: University of York)
BACKGROUND: Depression in older adults is common and is associated with poor quality of life, increased morbidity and early mortality, and increased health and social care use. Collaborative care, a low-intensity intervention for depression that is shown to be effective in working-age adults, has not yet been evaluated in older people with depression who are managed in UK primary care. The CollAborative care for Screen-Positive EldeRs (CASPER) plus trial fills the evidence gap identified by the most recent guidelines on depression management. OBJECTIVES: To establish the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of collaborative care for older adults with major depressive disorder in primary care. DESIGN: A pragmatic, multicentred, two-arm, parallel, individually randomised controlled trial with embedded qualitative study. Participants were automatically randomised by computer, by the York Trials Unit Randomisation Service, on a 1 : 1 basis using simple unstratified randomisation after informed consent and baseline measures were collected. Blinding was not possible. SETTING: Sixty-nine general practices in the north of England. PARTICIPANTS: A total of 485 participants aged ≥ 65 years with major depressive disorder. INTERVENTIONS: A low-intensity intervention of collaborative care, including behavioural activation, delivered by a case manager for an average of six sessions over 7-8 weeks, alongside usual general practitioner (GP) care. The control arm received only usual GP care. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcome measure was Patient Health Questionnaire-9 items score at 4 months post randomisation. Secondary outcome measures included depression severity and caseness at 12 and 18 months, the EuroQol-5 Dimensions, Short Form questionnaire-12 items, Patient Health Questionnaire-15 items, Generalised Anxiety Disorder-7 items, Connor-Davidson Resilience Scale-2 items, a medication questionnaire, objective data and adverse events. Participants were followed up at 12 and 18 months. RESULTS: In total, 485 participants were randomised (collaborative care, n = 249; usual care, n = 236), with 390 participants (80%: collaborative care, 75%; usual care, 86%) followed up at 4 months, 358 participants (74%: collaborative care, 70%; usual care, 78%) followed up at 12 months and 344 participants (71%: collaborative care, 67%; usual care, 75%) followed up at 18 months. A total of 415 participants were included in primary analysis (collaborative care, n = 198; usual care, n = 217), which revealed a statistically significant effect in favour of collaborative care at the primary end point at 4 months [8.98 vs. 10.90 score points, mean difference 1.92 score points, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.85 to 2.99 score points; p  < 0.001], equivalent to a standard effect size of 0.34. However, treatment differences were not maintained in the longer term (at 12 months: 0.19 score points, 95% CI -0.92 to 1.29 score points; p = 0.741; at 18 months: < 0.01 score points, 95% CI -1.12 to 1.12 score points; p = 0.997). The study recorded details of all serious adverse events (SAEs), which consisted of 'unscheduled hospitalisation', 'other medically important condition' and 'death'. No SAEs were related to the intervention. Collaborative care showed a small but non-significant increase in quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) over the 18-month period, with a higher cost. Overall, the mean cost per incremental QALY for collaborative care compared with usual care was £26,016; however, for participants attending six or more sessions, collaborative care appears to represent better value for money (£9876/QALY). LIMITATIONS: Study limitations are identified at different stages: design (blinding unfeasible, potential contamination), process (relatively low overall consent rate, differential attrition/retention rates) and analysis (no baseline health-care resource cost or secondary/social care data). CONCLUSION: Collaborative care was effective for older people with case-level depression across a range of outcomes in the short term though the reduction in depression severity was not maintained over the longer term of 12 or 18 months. Participants who received six or more sessions of collaborative care did benefit substantially more than those who received fewer treatment sessions but this difference was not statistically significant. FUTURE WORK RECOMMENDATIONS: Recommendations for future research include investigating the longer-term effect of the intervention. Depression is a recurrent disorder and it would be useful to assess its impact on relapse and the prevention of future case-level depression. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN45842879. FUNDING: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme and will be published in full in Health Technology Assessment; Vol. 21, No. 67. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information.
Figures & Tables
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
7 Citations
17 Authors (David Richards, ..., Michael Barkham)
147 Citations
10 Citations
#1Helen J Lewis (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 6
#2Joy Adamson (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 34
Last. Simon Gilbody (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 80
view all 34 authors...
BACKGROUND: Efforts to reduce the burden of illness and personal suffering associated with depression in older adults have focused on those with more severe depressive syndromes. Less attention has been paid to those with mild disorders/subthreshold depression, but these patients also suffer significant impairments in their quality of life and level of functioning. There is currently no clear evidence-based guidance regarding treatment for this patient group. OBJECTIVES: To establish the clinica...
7 CitationsSource
#1Simon Gilbody (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 80
#2Helen J Lewis (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 6
Last. Dean McMillan (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 32
view all 32 authors...
Importance There is little evidence to guide management of depressive symptoms in older people. Objective To evaluate whether a collaborative care intervention can reduce depressive symptoms and prevent more severe depression in older people. Design, Setting, and Participants Randomized clinical trial conducted from May 24, 2011, to November 14, 2014, in 32 primary care centers in the United Kingdom among 705 participants aged 65 years or older with Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Di...
52 CitationsSource
#1Joanna L. Hudson ('KCL': King's College London)H-Index: 9
#2Peter Bower (MAHSC: Manchester Academic Health Science Centre)H-Index: 90
Last. Peter A. Coventry (MAHSC: Manchester Academic Health Science Centre)H-Index: 31
view all 4 authors...
Abstract Background Collaborative care has proven efficacy in improving symptoms of depression, yet patients value improvements in their social function also. We used the World Health Organisation's International classification of functioning, disability, and health (WHO ICF) to robustly identify measures of social function and explored whether collaborative care interventions improve social functioning using meta-analysis. Methods We performed a secondary data analysis on studies identified fro...
9 CitationsSource
#1Karen Overend (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 7
#2Katharine Bosanquet (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 5
Last. Carolyn Chew-Graham (Keele University)H-Index: 63
view all 10 authors...
The prevalence of depressive symptoms in older people may be as high as 20 %. Depression in older people is associated with loss, loneliness and physical co-morbidities; it is known to be under-diagnosed and under-treated. Older people may find it difficult to speak to their GPs about low mood, and GPs may avoid identifying depression due to limited consultation time and referral options for older patients. A nested qualitative study in a randomised controlled trial for older people with moderat...
15 CitationsSource
#1Peter A. Coventry (MAHSC: Manchester Academic Health Science Centre)H-Index: 31
#2Karina Lovell (MAHSC: Manchester Academic Health Science Centre)H-Index: 58
Last. Linda Gask (MAHSC: Manchester Academic Health Science Centre)H-Index: 66
view all 16 authors...
Objective To test the effectiveness of an integrated collaborative care model for people with depression and long term physical conditions. Design Cluster randomised controlled trial. Setting 36 general practices in the north west of England. Participants 387 patients with a record of diabetes or heart disease, or both, who had depressive symptoms (≥10 on patient health questionaire-9 (PHQ-9)) for at least two weeks. Mean age was 58.5 (SD 11.7). Participants reported a mean of 6.2 (SD 3.0) long ...
182 CitationsSource
#1Madeline Pasterfield (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 3
#2Della Bailey (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 8
Last. Simon Gilbody (Hull York Medical School)H-Index: 80
view all 6 authors...
There is growing evidence that Behavioural Activation is an effective treatment for older adults with depression. However, there is a lack of detail given in studies about any adaptations made to interventions or efforts made to remove treatment barriers. Factors such as co-morbid physical health problems, cognitive impairment and problems with social support suggest there may be specific treatment considerations when developing interventions for this group. This article aims to describe adaptat...
19 CitationsSource
#1Colin Green (University of Exeter)H-Index: 49
#2David Richards (University of Exeter)H-Index: 106
Last. Michael Barkham (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 87
view all 17 authors...
Background Collaborative care is an effective treatment for the management of depression but evidence on its cost-effectiveness in the UK is lacking. Aims To assess the cost-effectiveness of collaborative care in a UK primary care setting. Methods An economic evaluation alongside a multi-centre cluster randomised controlled trial comparing collaborative care with usual primary care for adults with depression (n = 581). Costs, quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs), and incremental cost-effectivenes...
33 CitationsSource
#1David Ekers (Durham University)H-Index: 14
#2Lisa A.D. Webster (Durham University)H-Index: 8
Last. Simon Gilbody (Hull York Medical School)H-Index: 80
view all 6 authors...
Background: Depression is a common, disabling condition for which psychological treatments are recommended. Behavioural activation has attracted increased interest in recent years. It has been over 5 years since our meta-analyses summarised the evidence supporting and this systematic review updates those findings and examines moderators of treatment effect. Method: Randomised trials of behavioural activation for depression versus controls or anti-depressant medication were identified using elect...
222 CitationsSource
#1A. Matthew Prina ('KCL': King's College London)H-Index: 21
#2Riccardo E. Marioni (University of Cambridge)H-Index: 60
Last. Tom Dening (University of Nottingham)H-Index: 38
view all 6 authors...
Background Evaluations of the Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) scheme have not yet focused on minority subgroups. This paper aims to evaluate accessibility, waiting times and clinical outcomes of IAPT for older adults.
18 CitationsSource
#1Sarah Knowles (MAHSC: Manchester Academic Health Science Centre)H-Index: 19
#2Carolyn Chew-Graham (Keele University)H-Index: 63
Last. Peter A. Coventry (MAHSC: Manchester Academic Health Science Centre)H-Index: 31
view all 7 authors...
Background: Mental-physical multi-morbidities pose challenges for primary care services that traditionally focus on single diseases. Collaborative care models encourage inter-professional working to deliver better care for patients with multiple chronic conditions, such as depression and long-term physical health problems. Successive trials from the United States have shown that collaborative care effectively improves depression outcomes, even in people with long-term conditions (LTCs), but litt...
56 CitationsSource
Cited By17
#1Andrew S Moriarty (Hull York Medical School)H-Index: 4
#2Lewis William Paton (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 8
Last. Dean McMillanH-Index: 32
view all 16 authors...
Most patients who present with depression are treated in primary care by general practitioners (GPs). Relapse of depression is common (at least 50% of patients treated for depression will relapse after a single episode) and leads to considerable morbidity and decreased quality of life for patients. The majority of patients will relapse within 6 months, and those with a history of relapse are more likely to relapse in the future than those with no such history. GPs see a largely undifferentiated ...
#1Simon Gilbody (Hull York Medical School)H-Index: 80
#2Sally Brabyn (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 13
Last. Kate Bosanquet (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 7
view all 11 authors...
BACKGROUND Treatment of established depression is the dominant approach to care of older adults, but prevention holds much promise. Self-help interventions are a feasible preventive approach, since they are scalable and low cost. There are few trials in this area. Behavioral Activation (BA) is a credible candidate psychological approach, which has been shown to work in therapist led care but not been trialled in a self-help form. AIM To test the effectiveness of an unguided self-help interventio...
1 CitationsSource
#1Inna Feldman (Uppsala University)H-Index: 13
#2Mihretab Gebreslassie (Uppsala University)H-Index: 1
Last. Richard Ssegonja (Uppsala University)H-Index: 6
view all 5 authors...
To review the literature on economic evaluations of public health interventions targeting prevention of mental health problems and suicide, to support evidence based societal resource allocation. A systematic review of economic evaluations within mental health and suicide prevention was conducted including studies published between January 2000 and November 2018. The studies were identified through Medline, PsychINFO, Web of Science, the National Health Service Economic Evaluation Database and H...
2 CitationsSource
#1Marcia Scazufca (USP: University of São Paulo)H-Index: 43
#2Carina Akemi Nakamura (USP: University of São Paulo)
Last. Ricardo Araya ('KCL': King's College London)H-Index: 76
view all 11 authors...
The elderly population has been growing in most low- and middle-income countries (LMIC), and depression is a common condition among these populations. The lack of integration between mental health and primary healthcare services and the shortage of mental health specialists in the public health system contribute to underdiagnosis and undertreatment of depression. One of the strategies to reduce this gap is task shifting and collaborative care treatments. This study therefore aims to evaluate the...
2 CitationsSource
#1Rebecca Appleton (Warw.: University of Warwick)H-Index: 4
#2Faraz Mughal (Warw.: University of Warwick)H-Index: 7
Last. Swaran P. Singh (Warw.: University of Warwick)H-Index: 60
view all 6 authors...
Mental illness represents the highest proportion of disease burden for children and young people in the UK.1 However, despite this, young people can struggle to access timely and appropriate mental health care. One particular barrier to continuity of care occurs when young people reach the upper age limit (usually 18 years) of child and adolescent mental health services (CAMHS). If they require ongoing specialist support, their care should be transferred to an adult mental health service (AMHS),...
1 CitationsSource
Patient-centred care by a coordinated primary care team may be more effective than standard care in chronic disease management. We synthesised evidence to determine whether patient-centred medical home (PCMH)-based care models are more effective than standard general practitioner (GP) care in improving biomedical, hospital, and economic outcomes. MEDLINE, CINAHL, Embase, Cochrane Library, and Scopus were searched to identify randomised (RCTs) and non-randomised controlled trials that evaluated t...
7 CitationsSource
#1Philippa LilfordH-Index: 2
#2Julian C. HughesH-Index: 28
#1Bruno Araújo da Silva Dantas (UFRN: Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte)H-Index: 2
#2Jéssica Maria Arouca de Miranda (UFRN: Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte)H-Index: 2
Last. Gilson de Vasconcelos Torres (UFRN: Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte)H-Index: 17
view all 10 authors...
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the impact of multidimensional interventions on quality of life (QoL) and depressive symptoms in Brazilian older adults living in the community. METHODS: Longitudinal, quasi-experimental study of older adults receiving conventional primary health care (PHC). The interventions were designed in response to a first round of data collection and validated through pilot testing in groups of older adults from another community. The validated interventions were then applied to an ...
2 CitationsSource
#1Matthew Menear (Laval University)H-Index: 21
#2Michèle Dugas (Laval University)H-Index: 5
view all 14 authors...
Abstract Background Patients and families are often referred to as important partners in collaborative mental health care (CMHC). However, how to meaningfully engage them as partners remains unclear. We aimed to identify strategies for engaging patients and families in CMHC programs for depression and anxiety disorders. Methods We updated a Cochrane review of CMHC programs for depression and anxiety disorders. Searches were conducted in Cochrane CCDAN and CINAHL, complemented by additional datab...
5 CitationsSource
#1Kathleen T. McCoy (USA: University of South Alabama)H-Index: 2
#2Christine B. Costa (LBSU: California State University, Long Beach)H-Index: 2
Last. Linda Sue Hammonds (USA: University of South Alabama)H-Index: 1
view all 4 authors...
: Depression management in primary care settings is the norm, in the United States and globally. As incidence and prevalence of depression continue to mount, there are innovative models of treatment, newer understandings, more open philosophies, and evidence-informed treatments that may address this troubling public health issue. This article attempts to succinctly examine the evidence in identifying and treating this in the United States in an expedient, evidence-informed manner to assist those...
1 CitationsSource