Overprecision in Judgment

Published on Dec 18, 2015
· DOI :10.1002/9781118468333.CH6
Don A. Moore53
Estimated H-index: 53
(University of California, Berkeley),
Elizabeth R. Tenney15
Estimated H-index: 15
(UofU: University of Utah),
Uriel Haran7
Estimated H-index: 7
(BGU: Ben-Gurion University of the Negev)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
116 Citations
315 Citations
633 Citations
#1Jennifer Marie Logg (Harvard University)H-Index: 8
#2Uriel Haran (BGU: Ben-Gurion University of the Negev)H-Index: 7
Last. Don A. Moore (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 53
view all 3 authors...
: Are overconfident beliefs driven by the motivation to view oneself positively? We test the relationship between motivation and overconfidence using two distinct, but often conflated measures: better-than-average (BTA) beliefs and overplacement. Our results suggest that motivation can indeed affect these faces of overconfidence, but only under limited conditions. Whereas BTA beliefs are inflated by motivation, introducing some specificity and clarity to the standards of assessment (Experiment 1...
15 CitationsSource
#1Don A. Moore (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 53
#2Ashli Carter (Columbia University)H-Index: 3
Last. Heather H. J. Yang (MIT: Massachusetts Institute of Technology)H-Index: 2
view all 3 authors...
Overprecision is the most robust and least understood form of overconfidence. In an attempt to elucidate the underlying causes of overprecision in judgment, the present paper offers a new approach – examining people’s beliefs about the likelihood of chance events drawn from known probability distributions. This approach allows us to test the assumption that low hit rates inside subjective confidence intervals arise because those confidence intervals are drawn too narrowly. In fact, subjective pr...
10 CitationsSource
We conduct two experimental tests of the claim that people are overconfident, using new tests of overplacement that are based on a formal Bayesian model. Our two experiments, on easy quizzes, find that people overplace themselves. More precisely, we find apparently overconfident data that cannot be accounted for by a rational population of expected utility maximizers who care only about money. The finding represents new evidence of overconfidence that is robust to the Bayesian critique offered b...
35 CitationsSource
#1Elizabeth R. Tenney (UofU: University of Utah)H-Index: 15
#2Jennifer Marie Logg (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 8
Last. Don A. Moore (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 53
view all 3 authors...
A series of experiments investigated why people value optimism and whether they are right to do so. In Experiments 1A and 1B, participants prescribed more optimism for someone implementing decisions than for someone deliberating, indicating that people prescribe optimism selectively, when it can affect performance. Furthermore, participants believed optimism improved outcomes when a person�s actions had considerable, rather than little, influence over the outcome (Experiment 2). Experiments 3 an...
42 CitationsSource
#1Bryan L. Bonner (UofU: University of Utah)H-Index: 15
#2Alexander R. Bolinger (ISU: Idaho State University)H-Index: 5
Groups often struggle to distinguish expert members from others who stand out for various reasons but may not be particularly knowledgeable (Littlepage & Mueller, 1997). We examined an intervention designed to improve group decision making and performance through instructing group members to search for information they already possessed that was relevant to a problem. Participants estimated values and expressed their confidence in their estimates individually and then a second time either indivi...
19 CitationsSource
#1Jessica A. Kennedy (UPenn: University of Pennsylvania)H-Index: 11
#2Cameron Anderson (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 35
Last. Don A. Moore (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 53
view all 3 authors...
The status-enhancement theory of overconfidence proposes that overconfidence pervades self-judgment because it helps people attain higher social status. Prior work has found that highly confident individuals attained higher status regardless of whether their confidence was justified by actual ability (Anderson, Brion, Moore, & Kennedy, 2012). However, those initial findings were observed in contexts where individuals’ actual abilities were unlikely to be discovered by others. What happens to ove...
80 CitationsSource
#1Gavin J. Kilduff (NYU: New York University)H-Index: 12
#2Adam D. Galinsky (Columbia University)H-Index: 103
We propose that the psychological states individuals bring into newly formed groups can produce meaningful differences in status attainment. Three experiments explored whether experimentally created approach-oriented mindsets affected status attainment in groups, both immediately and over time. We predicted that approach-oriented states would lead to greater status attainment by increasing proactive behavior. Furthermore, we hypothesized that these status gains would persist longitudinally, days...
38 CitationsSource
#1Ulrich Sonnemann (WWU: University of Münster)H-Index: 2
#2Colin F. Camerer (California Institute of Technology)H-Index: 129
Last. Thomas Langer (WWU: University of Münster)H-Index: 15
view all 4 authors...
A fundamental debate in social sciences concerns how individual judgments and choices, resulting from psychological mechanisms, are manifested in collective economic behavior. Economists emphasize the capacity of markets to aggregate information distributed among traders into rational equilibrium prices. However, psychologists have identified pervasive and systematic biases in individual judgment that they generally assume will affect collective behavior. In particular, recent studies have found...
53 CitationsSource
#1Sunita Sah (Harvard University)H-Index: 17
#2Don A. Moore (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 53
Last. Robert J. MacCoun (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 50
view all 3 authors...
Is it possible to increase one’s influence simply by behaving more confidently? Prior research presents two competing hypotheses: (1) the confidence heuristic holds that more confidence increases credibility, and (2) the calibration hypothesis asserts that overconfidence will backfire when others find out. Study 1 reveals that, consistent with the calibration hypothesis, while accurate advisors benefit from displaying confidence, confident but inaccurate advisors receive low credibility ratings....
54 CitationsSource
#1Albert E. Mannes (UPenn: University of Pennsylvania)H-Index: 7
#2Don A. Moore (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 53
Overprecision—an excessive confidence that one knows the truth—is both the most durable and the least understood form of overconfidence. This article outlines an approach to the study of overprecision that avoids some of the methodological problems of other approaches and better reflects the way uncertainty affects choices in everyday life. We measured the precision in judgment implied by people’s tendency to adjust their point estimates of an uncertain quantity in response to the costs of overe...
28 CitationsSource
Cited By66
Abstract null null Men and women systematically differ in their beliefs about their performance relative to others; in particular, men tend to be more overconfident. This paper provides support for one explanation for gender differences in overconfidence, performance-motivated reasoning, in which people distort how they process new information in ways that make them believe they outperformed others. Using a large online experiment, I find that male subjects distort information processing in ways...
1 CitationsSource
#1Malte Knüppel (BBk: Deutsche Bundesbank)H-Index: 6
#2Fabian Krüger (KIT: Karlsruhe Institute of Technology)H-Index: 9
The linear pool is the most popular method for combining density forecasts. We analyze the linear pool's implications concerning forecast uncertainty in a new theoretical framework that focuses on the mean and variance of each density forecast to be combined. Our results show that, if the variance predictions of the individual forecasts are unbiased, the well-known 'disagreement' component of the linear pool exacerbates the upward bias of the linear pool's variance prediction. Moreover, we find ...
1 CitationsSource
We conduct an online survey experiment to investigate determinants of macroeconomic expectations. We investigate the effect of probability overweighting, religiosity, ambiguity aversion, and time preference. We find that subjects exhibiting probability overweighting, having higher degree of religiosity, having lower discount factor are more optimistic on economic growth and income, while ambiguity averse subjects are more pessimistic about the impact of Covid-19 outbreak on the economic growth r...
#1Edmond BerishaH-Index: 4
#2John MeszarosH-Index: 4
Last. Rangan GuptaH-Index: 57
view all 3 authors...
This paper studies the secular increase in US income inequality and its relation to growing house prices over the past three decades. We explore income inequality's effect on house prices based on a high-frequency (quarterly) data-set for all US states, including the District of Columbia. The analysis show that higher income inequality decreases the growth rate of house prices. However, the relationship differs for the Northeast region. We find higher income inequality corresponds with higher ho...
#1Max BreitenlechnerH-Index: 3
#2Georgios GeorgiadisH-Index: 10
Last. Ben SchumannH-Index: 1
view all 3 authors...
We quantify spillbacks from US monetary policy based on structural scenario analysis and minimum relative entropy methods applied in a Bayesian proxy structural vector-autoregressive model for the time period from 1990 to 2019. We find that spillbacks account for up to half of the overall slowdown in domestic real activity in response to a contractionary US monetary policy shock. Moreover, spillbacks materialise as stock market wealth effects impinge on US consumption, and as Tobin's q effects i...
#1Daniel N. Hauser (Aalto University)H-Index: 1
#2J. Aislinn Bohren (UPenn: University of Pennsylvania)H-Index: 7
This paper develops a general framework to study how misinterpreting information impacts learning. Our main result is a simple criterion to characterize long-run beliefs based on the underlying form of misspecification. We present this characterization in the context of social learning, then highlight how it applies to other learning environments, including individual learning. A key contribution is that our characterization applies to settings with model heterogeneity and provides conditions fo...
1 CitationsSource
#1Cuimin Ba (UPenn: University of Pennsylvania)H-Index: 1
#2Alice Gindin (UPenn: University of Pennsylvania)H-Index: 1
Overconfidence has been extensively documented in psychology and economics. This paper studies the long-term interaction between two overconfident agents who learn about common payoff-relevant fundamentals, such as the quality of a joint project or their working environment, and choose how much effort to exert. Overconfidence causes agents to underestimate the fundamental to justify their worse-than-expected performance. We show that in many settings, agents create informational externalities fo...
2 CitationsSource
The crux of policy analyses rests with its effectiveness in altering consumer behavior. However, the vast difference across individuals gives rise to a substantial variation in their response to policy shocks. One of representative heterogeneities is the level of liquid assets held by each family. Using the macro-level and household-level data from 20 European countries, this paper attempts to unravel how Hand-to-Mouth (HtM) households, who retain little or no liquid wealth, affects the transmis...
A fundamental aspect of China's transition to a market economy is the change of fiscal decentralization marked by the tax reform in 1993. This paper examines the effect of revenue and expenditure decentralization and their divergences on fiscal spending multipliers in China using nationally aggregate and provincial-level data from 1978 to 2017. Our investigations show that expenditure decentralization weakens the efficacy of spending policies, while revenue decentralization enhances the efficacy...
In 1998, I published a paper that showed that under a wide range of specifications, residential investment led GDP, while non-residential investment did not. That papers was followed by a number of others, including Coulson and Kim (2000), Davis and Heathcoate (2005) and Leamer (2007) that used more sophisticated techniques than my paper, but found the same outcome— that residential investment led GDP. Leamer famously announced that housing was the business cycle. But in light of the Great Finan...