Orbital Blowout Fractures: Experimental Evidence for the Pure Hydraulic Theory

Published on Apr 1, 2002in Archives of Facial Plastic Surgery
· DOI :10.1001/ARCHFACI.4.2.98
John S. Rhee33
Estimated H-index: 33
John Kilde2
Estimated H-index: 2
+ 1 AuthorsFrank A. Pintar74
Estimated H-index: 74
Background  The mechanism of injury and the underlying biomechanics of orbital blowout fractures remain controversial. The "hydraulic" theory proposes that a generalized increased orbital content pressure results in direct compression and fracturing of the thin orbital bone. Objective  To examine the pure hydraulic mechanism of injury by eliminating the factor of globe-to-wall contact and its possible contribution to fracture thresholds and patterns. Materials and Methods  Five fresh human cadaver specimens were used for the study. In each cadaver head, 1 orbit was prepared to mimic the normal physiologic condition by increasing the hypotony of the cadaver globe to normal intraocular pressure (15-20 mm Hg) with intravitreous injection of isotonic sodium chloride solution (saline). The second orbit served as a "hydraulic control," whereby the globe and orbital contents were exenterated and replaced by a saline-filled balloon at physiologic intraocular pressure. A 1-kg pendulum measuring 2.5 cm in diameter was used to strike the cadaver heads. Drop heights ranged from 0.2 m to 1.1 m (1960 mJ to 10 780 mJ energy). Each head was struck twice, once to each orbit. Direct visualization, high-speed videography, and computed tomographic scans were used to determine injury patterns at various heights between the 2 orbits. Results  A fracture threshold was found at a drop height of 0.3 m (2940 mJ). Fracture severity and displacement increased with incremental increases in drop height (energy). Fracture displacement, with herniation of orbital contents, was obtained at heights above 0.5 m (4900 mJ). Isolated orbital floor fractures were obtained at lower heights, with medial wall fractures occurring in conjunction with floor fractures at higher energies (≥6860 mJ). The globe intact side and balloon (hydraulic control) side showed nearly identical fracture patterns and levels of displacement at each drop height. Conclusions  This study provides support for the "hydraulic" theory and evidence against the role of direct globe-to-wall contact in the pathogenesis of orbital blowout fractures. In addition, the orbital floor was found to have a lower threshold for fracture than the medial wall. Preliminary threshold values for fracture occurrence and soft tissue displacement were obtained.
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
106 Citations
403 Citations
71 Citations
#1Norman WaterhouseH-Index: 14
#2J. Lyne (Imperial College London)H-Index: 2
Last. L.J. Garey (Imperial College London)H-Index: 2
view all 4 authors...
Abstract For over a century, since the first description of an orbital ‘blowout’ fracture, there has been debate and confusion regarding the mechanism of production of these fractures. An orbital blowout fracture throughout this paper refers to fractures exhibiting displacement of the orbital floor or walls without an associated fracture of the orbital rim. These are the so called ‘pure’ blowout fractures as described by Converse. Involvement of the orbit in a variety of facial fracture patterns...
106 CitationsSource
#1Lena Folkestad (University of Gothenburg)H-Index: 4
#2Thomas Westin (University of Gothenburg)H-Index: 21
A surgical technique involving exact repositioning and rigid fixation is required for the reduction of fractures of the orbital floor. Even then, sequelae may be present long after the trauma. The aim of this study was to establish the frequency and type of sequelae after surgery for orbital floor fractures and to investigate the extent to which the method of surgery had any impact on the severity of the sequelae. A questionnaire was sent to all 107 patients (response rate 77%) 1 to 5 years afte...
64 CitationsSource
#1Brian F. Erling (JHUSOM: Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine)H-Index: 1
#2Nicholas T. IliffH-Index: 26
Last. Paul N. MansonH-Index: 61
view all 4 authors...
Multiple mechanisms of orbital blowout fractures have been proposed since the fracture was described at the beginning of this century. The original theory of direct globe-to-wall contact was abandoned long ago for the more contemporary hydraulic and bone conduction theories. Although the more widely
43 CitationsSource
#1David Hampson (Transport Research Laboratory)H-Index: 1
Abstract A review of biomechanical studies that have attempted to measure fracture tolerances of facial bones has been carried out. The particular bones of interest were the mandible, the zygoma, the maxilla and the nasal bones. Numerical values have been given for the peak force and pressure fracture tolerances for these bones. A study of these values illustrates just how variable the bone strength of various individuals is. A review of various methods that have attempted to measure and quantif...
48 CitationsSource
#1Phalen JjH-Index: 1
#2Baumel JjH-Index: 1
Last. Kaplan PaH-Index: 1
view all 3 authors...
: Historically, blow-out fractures were ascribed to backward displacement of the eyeball which increased the intraorbital pressure causing the floor to fracture. By using dry skull and cadaver specimens, we have shown that minimal trauma to the orbital rim produces a segmented fracture of the orbital floor without the presence of the eyeball. It appears, however, that the pressure from the bulb is necessary to produce a depressed fracture of the orbital floor.
8 Citations
: Current thought on the pathophysiology of orbital wall fractures postulates either a "hydraulic" or a "buckling" mechanism. Evidence from cadaver, dried skull, and theoretical model studies supports both theories. No in vivo data, human or nonhuman primate, are available that quantitate the force necessary to fracture the orbital floor by either of the two mechanisms. We developed an apparatus that delivers quantifiable force only to the globe, without occluding the orbital opening or striking...
61 CitationsSource
• Enophthalmos, hypophthalmos, and diplopia are complications of orbital injury. This article reviews the causes of these sequelae, describes a method of strategic implantation of bone grafts to the orbit (and malar bone), and reports the long-term (six months to eight years) results in 38 cases. As a result of bone grafting, all but two patients had a correction of the enophthalmos to within 1 to 2 mm of the opposite eye. Of the 20 patients with diplopia, 15 had correction, and an additional fo...
35 CitationsSource
At the spring meeting of the American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery in Palm Beach, Fla, Drs Robert Hillstrom, Robert H. Mathog, and Frank A. Nesi, Wayne State University, Detroit, described the surgical correction of enophthalmos and diplopia in 38 cases of facial trauma. Injury to the orbit can cause enophthalmos, hypophthalmos, and diplopia. All cases were treated by grafting hip bone subperiosteally within the orbit to increase orbital volume to correct enophthalmos or ...
12 CitationsSource
147 CitationsSource
91 CitationsSource
Cited By67
#1Marcin Adam Zmuda Trzebiatowski (GUT: Gdańsk University of Technology)H-Index: 2
#2Paweł Kłosowski (GUT: Gdańsk University of Technology)H-Index: 9
Last. Mateusz Koberda (Gdańsk Medical University)H-Index: 1
view all 6 authors...
The more we know about mechanisms of the human orbital blowout type of trauma, the better we will be able to prevent them in the future. As long as the buckling mechanism’s veracity is not in doubt, the hydraulic mechanism is not based on equally strong premises. To investigate the correctness of the hydraulic mechanism’s theory, two different methods of implementation of the hydraulic load to the finite element method (FEM) model of the orbit were performed. The intraorbital hydraulic pressure ...
#1Hoon Noh (SMC: Samsung Medical Center)H-Index: 1
#2Joon Kyo Chung (SMC: Samsung Medical Center)H-Index: 1
Last. Yoon-Duck Kim (SMC: Samsung Medical Center)H-Index: 17
view all 4 authors...
PURPOSE To analyze the prevalence and association of ocular injury and orbital fracture in orbital trauma patients METHODS: Patients with periocular trauma who visited the emergency room at the referral center from 2014 to 2016 were screened. Patients examined by ophthalmologists and evaluated by CT scan were included. Patients' age, gender, cause of trauma, and injury patterns were retrieved. The location of the fracture and morphologic parameters were reviewed. The patients were divided into g...
1 CitationsSource
#1Ayham DarwichH-Index: 3
Last. Hasan Nazha (University of Miskolc)H-Index: 2
view all 5 authors...
Abstract Introduction Orbital wall fractures consider one of the most common fractures in the maxillofacial trauma. These fractures caused by two mechanisms as thought, the buckling mechanism and hydraulic mechanism. This study aims to compare between the two mechanisms in terms of intensity and extension using the finite elements method. Material and methods Three-dimensional model of the skull was generated using computed tomography data of young male patient. Virtual loads were applied on the...
#1Zulma Catherine (University of Geneva)H-Index: 3
#2Delphine S. Courvoisier (University of Geneva)H-Index: 34
Last. Paolo Scolozzi (University of Geneva)H-Index: 15
view all 3 authors...
Abstract Objective To determine the association of “pure” orbital fractures (POF) and “impure” orbital fractures (IOF) with ocular and periocular injuries. Materials and methods A retrospective study of patients with orbital fractures was designed. The predictor variable was the orbital's fracture configuration (pure versus impure). The primary outcome variables were ocular and periocular injuries classified as mild, moderate, and severe. The secondary outcome was the need for surgical repair. S...
3 CitationsSource
#1Jong Ho Ahn (Gachon University)
#3Su Jin Park (Gachon University)
Last. Mi Jung Chi (Gachon University)H-Index: 3
view all 3 authors...
#1Alex T. Legocki (Mount Sinai Health System)H-Index: 1
#2B. Miles (Mount Sinai Health System)H-Index: 4
Background Orbital reconstruction following oncologic midface resection is uniquely challenging, and makes critical contributions to patient aesthetics, function, and identity. Approach is largely dependent on surgeon and patient preferences, and there exists no consensus on defect characterization. Objective The goal of the study is to provide a mental framework for the reconstructive oncologic surgeon to use as a foundation during his or her approach to the orbit. Design The design of the stud...
1 CitationsSource
#1Rahel Joss (UZH: University of Zurich)
#2Fabio Baschnagel (Empa: Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology)H-Index: 2
Last. Andrea S Bischofberger (UZH: University of Zurich)H-Index: 11
view all 6 authors...
Objective The aim of this study was to compare the potential of an unshod and shod hoof to cause an orbital fracture in the event of a kick. Materials and Methods Thirty-four equine cadaveric orbitae were exposed to a steel or horn impactor in a dropping test set-up. An impactor velocity of 7 m/s was used for both materials. Testing was repeated on the same orbit at a velocity of 10 m/s with the horn impactor if no damage occurred. A high-speed camera was used to analyse the impact process. Phys...
#1Sathyadeepak Ramesh (UCLA: University of California, Los Angeles)H-Index: 5
Last. Daniel B. RootmanH-Index: 21
view all 6 authors...
PURPOSE: To study whether ethmoidectomy predisposes the orbit to medial wall fracture with lesser trauma. METHODS: An interventional cadaver study of 5 heads (10 orbits); the left or right orbit was randomized to undergo endoscopic complete ethmoidectomy with the fellow orbit as control. Fractures were induced with direct globe trauma, and heads underwent CT scanning. Energy to induce fracture, peak orbital pressure at time of fracture, fracture pattern, and volume of herniated tissue were measu...
4 CitationsSource
#1Scott E. Bevans (San Antonio Military Medical Center)H-Index: 3
#2Kris S. Moe (UW: University of Washington)H-Index: 27
: Orbital reconstruction is one of the most challenging tasks for surgeons who treat craniofacial trauma. Suboptimal outcomes carry a high level of morbidity, with functional, emotional, and aesthetic implications. However, advances in reconstruction techniques, including the use of orbital endoscopy, computer-guided navigation, and mirror image overlay techniques, have been shown to provide significant improvements in outcomes. This article provides practical advice for applying these technique...
12 CitationsSource